November 2026, Provincial Animal Welfare Services (AWS) posted on Facebook with their chest puffed out in pride about 3 recent cases of animal cruelty resulting in convictions.
Humane Initiative is highlighting 1 case:
Samara Flaro of Roseneath, Ontario (Township of Alnwick/Haldimand in Northumberland County). See below for the charges laid and the penalty/fines imposed after conviction under the Provincial Offences Act (POA) in a Cobourg court on September 16, 2026.
Do YOU think the penalty was strict enough?
We want to do a deeper dive into this case and bring our findings to you.
First and foremost, lets highlight this date: September 16, 2026 – Samara Flaro Found GUILTY
The other overreaching issue here is Samara Flaro DID NOT possess the required municipal kennel license. Maximum number of dogs allowed without this license is 3 dogs.
WHY did the municipality allow them to continue without a kennel licence? Did AWS ask the municipality if there was a kennel licence for this property?
AWS CHARGES:
- Causing an animal to be in distress (MAJOR Offence)
- Permitting an animal to be in distress (MAJOR Offence)
- 3 x Failing to comply with Standards of Care (MINOR Offence)
- 2 x Operating a puppy mill (MAJOR Offence)
PENALTIES/FINES IMPOSED:
- Fine of $350
- 7 days in custody
- 2 years probation
- Prohibited from owning animals for life (with certain conditions – which are not public.)
- AWS has the right to inspect residence 2 x each year for a period of 5 years
(ONLY 2 times and will they even bother to inspect?)
SO THAT IS THE “SENTENCE” THEY RECEIVED &
HERE IS WHAT IS RECOMMENDED…
- MAJOR OFFENCE:
- fine not more than $130,000
- Imprisonment not more than 2 years
- MINOR OFFENCE:
- fine not more than $75,000
- imprisonment not more than 6 months
SO WE ASK YOU – GIVEN WHAT IS ALLOWED – IS THE PENALTY ENOUGH? DOES IT SEND A DETERRENT? IS IT A PUNISHMENT – OR IS IT A JOKE?
NEXT, LET’S LOOK AT THE TIMELINE:
- December 2019:
- Neighbour files a complaint and has video showing Ms. Flaro yelling at and hitting a golden retriever with a stick. Video shows strikes, dog wincing and cowering
- YET, if there was even an investigation as far as anyone can tell, there was NOT any action taken
Between December 2019 and the removal date of October 26, 2021 AWS Inspector Renee Baker indicates she had approximately 25 conversations with Samara Flaro and approximately 20 visits to her Roseneath, Ontario property. (LET THAT SINK IN!)
- AWS Compliance Orders (demanding improvements be made) are issued during this time by AWS Inspectors
- Ms. Flaro admits she DOES NOT possess the REQUIRED kennel license
- Ms. Flaro admits she breeds golden retrievers and dachshunds and sells them online via social media
NOTE: Ms. Flaro ADMITS she breeds golden retrievers and dachshunds and sells them online via social media.
HELLO. In that 22 months alone AWS is more than aware of the suffering of the animals in her so-called care.
AWS are AWARE that she is running a puppy mill – 25 CONVERSATIONS and 20 PHYSICAL visits to the property – again in that 22 months alone.
AWS left an ADMITTED PUPPY MILL OPERATING and animals suffering.
WHAT? As soon as it is determined that there is not a kennel license, which is required… right then this puppy mill should have been shut down. And charges laid!
- Oct 26/2021:
- a warrant is executed and 11 dogs – none of whom were spayed or neutered, I kitten and 1 rabbit are removed from Ms. Flaro’s Roseneath property.
A veterinarian signed approval for removal after virtual walk-around and examination- 11 Dogs: 2 adult males, 6 adult females, 3 puppies removed and taken to Kingston Humane Society for veterinary assessment and care
- 5 deemed “emaciated”, a body score of 1 out of 9
- 5 deemed “thin”, body score of 2 out of 9
- 1 was “low normal”, body score of 3 out of 9
- blood work showed severe deficiencies that would indicate “prolonged starvation”
- 11 Dogs: 2 adult males, 6 adult females, 3 puppies removed and taken to Kingston Humane Society for veterinary assessment and care
- Conditions upon entering the premises:
- several dogs kept in small travel crates unable to stand, turnaround or lay down
- dogs in poor physical condition
- poor standards of care where dogs are soaked in urine, no bedding, no water or food
- a warrant is executed and 11 dogs – none of whom were spayed or neutered, I kitten and 1 rabbit are removed from Ms. Flaro’s Roseneath property.
Lets look at Scarlett, an 8-9 month old female golden retriever:
- Scarlett was kept in a travel crate and made it impossible for her to stand, turnaround or lay down
- no bedding, no access to drinking water
- crate bottom and her body were soaked in urine
- emaciated body condition
Now lets look at the 3 puppies:
- all golden retrievers
- found in a dark basement, no light (artificial or natural). A flashlight was required
- all three puppies were in one small travel crate
- no food or drinking water
- they were unable to move around
- all were covered in urine and feces
- body condition was emaciated
- toxic level of ammonia was registered in the basement
- January 24, 2022:
- Samara Flaro attempts to regain ownership of of her animals by appearing before an Animal Care Review Board (ACRB) tribunal
- The tribunal finds that AWS was within their rights to remove the animals and she is NOT to get her animals back.
- Samara Flaro attempts to regain ownership of of her animals by appearing before an Animal Care Review Board (ACRB) tribunal
- PLUS Samara Flaro owes via a Statement of Account for costs to care for the dogs after removal is:
- As of November 2021 – the cost for care was at $15,450
- Q: Bill ever collected on? This is paid for by Ontario taxpayers
No date can be found to indicate when AWS filed animal cruelty charges against Samara Flaro.
September 16, 2026 – Samara Flaro is convicted in Provincial Offences Court which means NO criminal record.
WE ASK YOU – ARE YOU OKAY WITH THIS?
- Ms. Flaro had no municipal kennel license which IS REQUIRED
- Therefore, she was not permitted to have more than 3 dogs on her property
- She admitted she was breeding for the purposes of selling on social media (AKA PUPPY MILL!)
- RIGHT, THEN AND THERE SHE SHOULD HAVE BEEN SHUT DOWN
- Between December 2019 and October 2021 there 20 visits to the property
- WHAT WAS AWS WAITING FOR?
- Are you okay with how the animals suffered during the time AWS failed to remove the animals and press charges?
- ARE YOU OKAY WITH HOW MINIMAL THE PENALTY?
From the Blog



